Spanish Judge Throws Out Payá Family Lawsuit 6

By Juan O. Tamayo,

A Spanish judge has rejected a lawsuit against Cuban security officials filed by relatives of the late Havana dissident Oswaldo Payá, arguing that Spanish politician Angel Carromero already has declared himself responsible for the death of the democracy activist.

Judge Eloy Velasco also ruled that the death of Payá, founder of the Christian Liberation Movement, in a car crash last summer did not amount to a crime against humanity, and that the Spanish government also had already accepted that the crash was an accident.

Payá’s brother Carlos, a Madrid doctor, said Monday that he could not comment on the ruling until he consulted with the family lawyer. Velasco’s decision was published in several Madrid news outlets, apparently before lawyer Francisco Andujar Ramírez received a copy.

The lawsuit alleges that a Cuban State Security vehicle rammed a car driven by Carromero and forced it to crash, killing Payá and fellow dissident Harold Cepero on July 22, 2012. Carromero and Swedish politician Jens Aron Modig suffered minor injuries.

A Cuban court found Carromero was speeding, lost control of his rented car and crashed on his own. He was convicted of vehicular homicide and sentenced to four years in prison, but was freed in December to serve the rest of his sentence in Spain.

Velasco ruled that Carromero accepted the Cuban version in a pre-trial video and during his one-day trial, and that the Spanish government had “explicitly recognized” the verdict as part of the bilateral agreement that allowed Carromero to fly home.

The allegation that the crash was caused by State Security “cannot be verified,” the judge wrote, adding that Carromero’s driving record was full of infractions and noting that Modig, who claimed to have been asleep before the crash, was not “alerted or woken up … even though (Carromero) claims they were being chased.”

The lawsuit argued that the Spanish court had jurisdiction over Payá’s death because he was a Spanish citizen and his death was a crime against humanity, due to its political overtones, but Velasco ruled the case did not meet any of the requirements for a crime against humanity.

Trying Payá’s death again before a Spanish court would amount to a kind of double jeopardy, the judge wrote in his ruling, and to having a Spanish court “review” the Cuban court’s sentence just because Payá had Spanish citizenship.

The lawsuit was filed by Payá’s widow and daughter and specifically named State Security Lt. Col. José Águilas, chief investigator for crimes against the security of the state, and a Col. Llanes, identified as the officer in charge of monitoring Payá’s dissident activities.

Velasco’s ruling closely paralleled the recommendations sent to the judge Sept. 13 by prosecutor Teresa Sandoval, who argued that the lawsuit should be spiked because both Carromero and the Spanish government had already accepted that the death was accidental.

Carromero, a Madrid leader of the youth branch of Spain’s ruling Popular Party, went to Cuba with Modig, head of the youth branch of Sweden’s Christian Democratic Party, to deliver 8,000 Euros to democracy activists on the island on behalf of a Swedish foundation.



  1. If lawyer Francisco Andujer did not give a warning to Paya´s family in advance, he has swindled it, because the defining Rome Statute is crystal clear in demanding some kind of series for deeming murder as crime against humanity, and the death of Payá and Cepero is a single event.
    Moreover, no court would accept the charge of murder on the basis of Carromero´s testimony, completely refuted by the forensic photos of the Hyundai Accent he was driving at the time of the death. Spanish experts confirmed the authenticity of the photos and the pure fact that another car was not involve in the accident.
    Even so, there will be always an anti-Castroite faction ready to play the fool by taking anything against Castro, who usually wins due to absurdities like this.

  2. The free world should not be expecting anything positive out of the government of Spain that for decades has being an staunching and loyal supporter of the Castro regime,Why is Spain so interested in Cuba?Spain owns Hotels in the whole
    entire island of Cuba.Spain is waiting for a democratic transition in the island to add the island as a colony or autonomous republic.If Spain economically controls the island,it does not matters who govern the island,the ones that control the most assets would be the ones that will influence its politics.We must not forget that Castro’s father was an Spanish soldier that fought the US during the Spanish American war.

  3. The bottom line is that Paya was murdered by the assassins of the Cuban Ministry of the Interior.They have a long legacy of murder,from the interrogations in Villa Marista to the Firing squads of La Cabana.Whenever there is repression, assassinations and murders the Ministry of the Cuban interior would be involved.The MININT is a legitimate criminal organization and whenever there is a transition in this island the MININT should be the first one to be brought to justice along with the ones that were involved in Paya’s murder.

  4. Spain is the European country where Cuban agents do whatever they want.The political prisoners from Cuba are sent to Spain because Castro know that in Spain these prisoners would be followed and repressed by the Cuban agents and the Spanish authorities are most of the time manipulated by them.

  5. Sorry, TFS, the bottom line is that if Castro would have decided to murder Paya, no witness would have been left available to tell the story. Otherwise, Castroism wouldn´t be what it is. And again, the judge Velasco is far away from plotting with Castro interest. The case was crystal clear since the Spanish Police reviewed the forensic photos of Carromero´s car. No sign of collision in the rear bumper. Enough. Everything else is superfluous.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s